Why Some Things Dissolve and Others Do Not · seed 1 · A4, ink-friendly. The answer key prints on its own page for grown-ups.
En anglais

Why salt dives in and oil stays out

Science · Matter & Materials · ages 15-16
Name ______________________   Date ____________
  1. Dissolving pure sugar in pure water supplies many mobile ions, making the solution a good electrical conductor.

    Circle one:   True   False

  2. Sodium chloride dissolves in water until its grains are no longer visible. What happened to the dissolved salt?

    • Its sodium and chlorine atoms changed into water molecules
    • Its ions separated and became surrounded by water
    • Its particles stopped existing when the grains became invisible
  3. Oil is mostly nonpolar. Why does it form a separate layer instead of mixing evenly with water?

    • Oil-water contacts do not favour extensive mixing
    • Oil is denser than water, so its molecules cannot mix
    • Water changes oil into charged particles which float away
  4. In a supervised sodium acetate 'hot ice' demonstration, a cooled supersaturated solution crystallises after a seed crystal is added. What does the seed do?

    • It removes enough heat to freeze all the water in the solution
    • It turns the dissolved sodium acetate into a different substance
    • It supplies a starting surface where crystals can grow
  5. A nonpolar solid is poorly soluble in water. Which solvent type is usually a better choice to try, if no chemical reaction occurs?

    • A polar solvent, because opposite polarities often favour mixing with nonpolar solutes
    • Salt water, because its ions often improve contacts with poorly soluble nonpolar solutes
    • A nonpolar solvent, because similar interactions often favour mixing
  6. A solubility curve gives 70 g at 80°C and 40 g at 30°C per 100 g water. A saturated solution with 100 g water cools from 80°C to 30°C without water loss. Crystals form and equilibrium is reached. The crystals contain no water. How many grams of solute crystallise?

    Answer: ______________

  7. Two unknown solutions contain either 5 g sodium chloride or 5 g sugar per 100 g distilled water, at the same temperature. Both are fully dissolved. Which supervised test distinguishes them?

    • Compare total masses: the sugar solution must weigh more
    • Use a battery-powered conductivity tester: salt water conducts better
    • Filter both solutions: dissolved salt stays on the filter paper
  8. A student sees sugar grains remain after stirring sugar into oil and concludes that sugar cannot dissolve in any liquid. What is the problem with that conclusion?

    • One solvent test cannot establish insolubility in all solvents
    • Heating any solvent always dissolves every solid added to it
    • Remaining grains prove that sugar became a different substance
LightMySky · lightmysky.comW1-mt__njIrlqqqL-s1

Answer key

For grown-ups. Fold this page away before handing over the rest.

Why salt dives in and oil stays out W1-mt__njIrlqqqL-s1

  1. False · Sugar stays as neutral molecules and supplies no ions. It adds almost no conductivity to pure water.
  2. Its ions separated and became surrounded by water · Water separates existing sodium and chloride ions from the crystal and surrounds them. The salt remains present.
  3. Oil-water contacts do not favour extensive mixing · Oil and water attract each other, but their contacts do not favour extensive mixing. Density alone does not explain solubility.
  4. It supplies a starting surface where crystals can grow · The solution already exceeds its equilibrium solubility limit. The seed provides a surface where crystal growth can start.
  5. A nonpolar solvent, because similar interactions often favour mixing · A nonpolar solvent is usually the better prediction. Similar polarity does not guarantee high solubility for every pair.
  6. 30 · The solution starts with 70 g dissolved and retains 40 g at the cold equilibrium limit. Therefore 70 - 40 = 30 g crystallises.
  7. Use a battery-powered conductivity tester: salt water conducts better · Sodium chloride supplies mobile ions and conducts far better. Sugar remains neutral. Use a supervised battery-powered tester, never mains electricity.
  8. One solvent test cannot establish insolubility in all solvents · The observation concerns oil, not every solvent. Sugar can dissolve in water, where it can form hydrogen bonds.
Worksheet · LightMySky