En anglais

Comparing How Authors Treat the Same Theme

English · Reading Comprehension · ages 10-11

Name ______________________ Date ____________

A shy fox speaks at a meeting despite trembling. A mouse defends a friend despite fearing a cat. Which theme fits both actions?
- Courage can mean acting while afraid
- Courage means never feeling any fear
- Courage always means working without friends
Two stories are mysteries, and both make readers eager to learn who took a missing ring. What have you identified?
- A shared theme about the value of being honest
- A shared message about helping friends in trouble
- A shared genre and a feeling of suspense
Evidence from only one story is enough to explain how two authors develop a shared theme.
Circle one: True False
Two adventures show that preparation helps people face danger. In one, a hero checks a map before a journey. Which detail from the other best supports that shared theme?
- A hero packs supplies before crossing the desert
- A hero describes the sunset while crossing the desert
- A hero hears a song while crossing the desert
In A, readers hear a worried hero think, 'What if I get lost?' In B, readers see the hero grip a map, but hear no thoughts. Which choice differs?
- Whether readers are given the hero's thoughts
- Whether readers are given the hero's exact age
- Whether readers are given the hero's home address
Adventure A shows friends repairing their trust by admitting a lie. Adventure B shows friends repairing their trust by keeping a promise. Which comparison uses details from both?
- Both repair trust, through honesty in A and reliability in B
- Both repair trust, through winning races and earning prizes
- Both repair trust, through avoiding each other after arguments
Mystery A gives readers a clue in each chapter. Mystery B delays its main clues until the final chapter. Which technique differs?
- How the authors describe the suspects' appearances
- When the authors give readers useful information
- Where the authors place the detectives' homes
One story includes a family dinner and another includes a walk with a grandpa. These details alone prove both have the theme 'Families listen to one another.'
Circle one: True False
A character's hands shake before a dangerous crossing. The author does not name her feeling. Which interpretation is best supported?
- The shaking may help readers infer that she feels afraid
- The shaking proves every reader will feel exactly her fear
- The shaking proves the author forgot to describe any feeling
Mia says, 'These mysteries both have a missing necklace, so both teach that honesty earns trust.' What is missing from her reasoning?
- Proof that both necklaces have matching shapes and colours
- Evidence that actions and endings support that message
- Proof that both mysteries have matching chapter counts

Answer key

For grown-ups. Fold this page away before handing over the rest.

Comparing How Authors Treat the Same Theme W1-mt_jO0gHMk7Ti-s1

Courage can mean acting while afraid · Both characters feel fear and act anyway. Their actions support courage as acting while afraid.
A shared genre and a feeling of suspense · Mystery names the genre. Waiting to learn the answer can create suspense. These details do not establish a shared theme.
False · A comparison needs details from both stories. Evidence from one cannot establish what the other author does.
A hero packs supplies before crossing the desert · Packing supplies is preparation, like checking a map. The sunset and song do not show preparation.
Whether readers are given the hero's thoughts · A gives a private thought. B gives an action without a private thought. No contrast in age or address is given.
Both repair trust, through honesty in A and reliability in B · Admitting a lie supports honesty. Keeping a promise supports reliability. The other comparisons introduce actions not given.
When the authors give readers useful information · The contrast concerns when readers receive clues, not descriptions or locations.
False · Both details involve family, but neither says anyone listens. A shared topic alone does not prove that theme.
The shaking may help readers infer that she feels afraid · Shaking before danger can suggest fear. It does not prove every reader's reaction or that the author forgot something.
Evidence that actions and endings support that message · A missing necklace is a shared detail. Mia needs evidence of honesty and trust to establish her claimed theme.