Designing a Biological Experiment: Units, Controls and Randomisation · seed 1 · A4, ink-friendly. The answer key prints on its own page for grown-ups.

Designing an experiment that can convince

Science · Scientific Inquiry · ages 22-23
Name ______________________   Date ____________
  1. What is the experimental unit?

    • The smallest thing independently assigned to a treatment
    • Every single measurement the machine records
    • The largest room in the laboratory
  2. What must a design name before data collection?

    • The journal for submission
    • The treatments, the units, and the response
    • The color scheme for the figures
  3. Random assignment balances even the factors nobody thought to name.

    Circle one:   True   False

  4. Patients come from several clinics with different baselines. What do you do?

    • Block by clinic, then randomize treatments inside each block
    • Drop every clinic except the largest one
    • Assign all sick patients to the new drug
  5. Twenty plants share one treated tray. What is the honest n for that dose?

    • Twenty, one per plant
    • One tray, averaged to a single value
    • Forty, counting leaves as well
  6. What role does a placebo arm play in a human study?

    • It receives everything except the active factor, isolating the treatment gap
    • It guarantees every patient is cured
    • It replaces the need for random assignment
  7. A trial randomized well but recruited only volunteers from one gym. What is threatened?

    • Nothing, since randomization fixes everything
    • Internal causality, which now collapses
    • Generalization outside, since sampling was narrow
  8. A reviewer attacks a study with n equals 12 from two cages. What is the likely flaw?

    • The unit was miscounted: cages, not animals, were assigned
    • Twelve is always too small for any study
    • Reviewers may never question sample size
LightMySky · lightmysky.comW1-mt_Hc6BAdlkLf-s1

Answer key

For grown-ups. Fold this page away before handing over the rest.

Designing an experiment that can convince W1-mt_Hc6BAdlkLf-s1

  1. The smallest thing independently assigned to a treatment · Only independently assigned things count as units.
  2. The treatments, the units, and the response · Naming these three fixes what the study can conclude.
  3. True · Chance spreads unknown differences evenly so no group starts ahead.
  4. Block by clinic, then randomize treatments inside each block · Blocking keeps the known nuisance from masquerading as a treatment effect.
  5. One tray, averaged to a single value · The tray was assigned, so plants inside it are not independent.
  6. It receives everything except the active factor, isolating the treatment gap · Matched controls let any gap trace back to the treatment.
  7. Generalization outside, since sampling was narrow · Assignment defends inside claims, while sampling defends outside ones.
  8. The unit was miscounted: cages, not animals, were assigned · Name the unit and count it before collecting anything.
Worksheet · LightMySky