Comparing characters, settings and events
Compare and contrast two or more characters, settings, or events in a story or drama, drawing on specific details about how characters interact, settings influence action, or events connect
What a learner can do afterwards
- Choose a Venn-diagram arrangement that correctly sorts the character traits named in two descriptions
- Use specific setting details to explain a supported change in mood or a character's actions
- Explain a supported cause-and-effect link between story events and distinguish it from time order alone
1 · Read
You have described characters, settings and events using details. To compare them, explain similarities and differences. Contrasting focuses on differences. Match evidence to your claim: sharing a home town is a valid similarity, but does not show a shared personality. Use relevant words, actions, thoughts and relationships to explain a trait.
A Venn diagram uses two overlapping circles. Put shared traits in the overlap. Put a trait for one character inside that character's circle, outside the overlap. Check each trait against both descriptions. Mara shares lunch; Beth eats alone; both pet dogs. Different actions can suggest a shared trait: returning a pen on time and arriving when promised both suggest reliability.
Setting is where and when a story happens. Mood is the feeling a passage creates. Compare light, weather, sound and space to explain a possible mood change. Link a mood word to particular details in each scene. Setting can also affect actions. A new place does not guarantee changed feelings or behavior. Distinguish a supported possible influence from a reason the text states.
Jo talks freely in a bright park. In a stormy forest, she whispers and watches the shadows. Those forest details can help explain her caution. Later, a fallen tree blocks her path, so she takes another route. This link is stated: the obstacle changes her route. Setting can affect feelings or create a practical problem.
Compare events by asking what is alike, what differs and how they relate. Events may contrast or happen in time order without causing each other. A causal link needs evidence that one event helps bring about another. A shared story alone does not establish that link. Compare the same feature in each event, such as how characters respond.
Because, so and as a result can signal cause and effect. In "Because it rained, the game stopped," rain is the cause. The stopped game is the effect, the result of that cause. Check the reason and surrounding details. An event happening later does not by itself show that an earlier event caused it.
Comparing means using real text evidence to see how characters, settings, or events are alike, different, or connected.
Original lesson, questions and flashcards written for this learning dataset.
Two original readings and their fictional examples written for this learning dataset.
More to read
Compare the same feature
In this invented story, Asha checks the canoe straps before a trip. Kit checks the weather report. Both prepare for the group's safety, though they do different jobs.
Their actions support a comparison about preparation. Their shared blue coats would support a comparison about clothing, but not about care for the group. Select evidence that fits the feature you are comparing.
You can sort shared details and differences in a Venn diagram. Shared details belong in the overlap. A detail for one character belongs inside that character's circle, outside the overlap.
Now compare two settings. Wind at the shore carries the leader's words away. Inside the boathouse, everyone can hear. The leader says, 'Come inside so I can explain the route.' The words connect the move to a practical need. No change in anyone's feelings is required to explain it.
Name the relationship between events
In an invented story, a shop door jams. The owner says she cannot open the shop until it is repaired, then calls a repair worker. Her words explain how the jammed door prompts the call.
Another character draws in the morning and visits a cousin after lunch. These events have a time order. Without another detail, the drawing does not explain the visit.
Two rehearsals in the story offer a contrast. At the first, everyone interrupts. At the second, each person waits for the speaker to finish. Comparing the same behavior reveals a difference. Explaining why it changed would require more evidence.
Name the relationship your evidence supports. For a causal link, explain how an event brings about a result. For a contrast, identify what differs. For time order, identify what happens earlier and later. One pair of events can have more than one relationship, but each claim needs support.
2 · Watch
En anglaisTake it off screen
Where it sits
Learn first
This opens up
Where this leads
16 questions wait behind this lesson, each with its answer explained. Every answer feeds the sky: stars light as they are learned, and dim when it is time to come back.