LightMySky
به انگلیسی

Changing Scientific Knowledge

Evaluate competing scientific explanations about dinosaurs by weighing fossil evidence, understanding that scientific knowledge changes as new fossils are discovered and new methods of analysis are developed

No account needed. Progress saves in this browser.

What a learner can do afterwards

  • Give an example of a scientific idea about dinosaurs that changed when new evidence was found
  • Explain that different scientists may interpret the same fossil evidence differently
  • State that the best scientific explanation is the one supported by the most evidence from multiple sources

1 · Read

Long ago, scientists pictured dinosaurs as slow, dull-colored reptiles that dragged their tails on the ground. That picture came from the fossils and tools people had at the time. As new fossils turned up and new methods let scientists study bones in finer detail, the picture changed.

Try it together

In the 1990s, fossil hunters in China found dinosaur skeletons with feather traces preserved in the rock. Before that, most scientists pictured dinosaurs as scaly, like lizards. The new fossils showed that many dinosaurs, including close relatives of birds, had feathers. Scientists updated their picture because the evidence demanded it.

Scaly ideaNew fossilFeather idea
A single new fossil can turn an old idea into a new one.
Good to know

When two scientists disagree about a fossil, that does not mean one of them is wrong on purpose. They may be reading the same bones in different ways. The stronger explanation is usually the one backed by evidence from many fossils and many studies, not just one opinion.

Scientific ideas about dinosaurs change as new fossils and new methods bring in stronger evidence.

More to read

What color were extinct dinosaurs?

For a long time, artists drew dinosaurs in dull greens and browns, like lizards and crocodiles. Then scientists learned that dinosaurs were close relatives of birds, so artists started painting them in brighter colors. But did anyone actually find fossil proof of dinosaur color? For years the answer was no. Then researchers discovered that some fossils still held tiny structures called melanosomes, the same structures that give feathers and skin their color today. By studying the shape of these structures under a microscope, scientists finally found real evidence for the colors of a few feathered dinosaurs. This is a good example of how a scientific idea changed. Old dinosaur colors were just guesses.

Discarded theories for dinosaur extinction

Scientists have spent decades trying to figure out why the dinosaurs died out about 66 million years ago. Today most agree that a huge asteroid crashed into Earth, with volcanoes and climate changes possibly adding to the trouble. But scientists did not always think this. Over the years, people suggested other ideas too, like dinosaurs growing too big to survive, running out of food, or getting wiped out by disease. As paleontologists found more evidence, like ash layers in rock, chemical traces, and a giant impact crater, they were able to test each idea and drop the ones the evidence did not support. This shows how science really works. When new evidence shows up, scientists change their explanation to match it instead of holding onto an old guess.

Did dinosaurs travel in herds or packs?

Dinosaurs cannot tell us how they lived, so how do scientists know if some of them traveled in groups? The strongest clues come from trackways, which are long trails of fossilized footprints left in ancient mud. By studying how many footprints there are, how far apart they are, and whether they all point the same way, scientists can tell if several dinosaurs walked together at the same time. Bonebeds, where many skeletons of the same species turn up together, add even more evidence. When scientists combine trackway evidence with bonebed evidence, they build a much stronger case than either one alone. This is why paleontologists like to gather evidence from more than one source before settling on an explanation.

Linking birds and dinosaurs

In the late 1800s, scientists found an amazing fossil in Germany called Archaeopteryx. It had feathers and wings like a bird, but also teeth, a long bony tail, and claws like a dinosaur. Right away, some scientists noticed it linked birds and dinosaurs together. Since then, paleontologists have found many more feathered dinosaur fossils that back up this connection, including dinosaurs with wishbones and hollow bones just like birds have. Each new fossil adds more evidence to the same idea. This shows how a scientific explanation gets stronger over time, not from one lucky find, but from many different fossils from different places all pointing to the same conclusion.

Are any dinosaurs still alive today?

For a long time, most people thought every dinosaur died out 66 million years ago. Today scientists classify birds as living dinosaurs, because birds evolved from small feathered dinosaurs and share many of their features, like hollow bones and wishbones. Other than birds, there is no fossil evidence that dinosaurs like Tyrannosaurus or Triceratops survived. Scientists changed how they group these animals as more fossils turned up connecting birds to dinosaur ancestors. This shows that how we classify living things is not set in stone forever. As paleontologists gather more fossil evidence, they sometimes have to redraw the lines between groups of animals.

Explore more

2 · Watch

به انگلیسی

Take it off screen

Print a worksheetA4 with an answer key page for grown-ups. No screen, no internet.

Where it sits

Where this leads

Jobs that lean on this skill. Follow one to see everything it is built on.

Then practise

8 questions wait behind this lesson, each with its answer explained. Every answer feeds the sky: stars light as they are learned, and dim when it is time to come back.

Spotted a problem on this page? Tell us
Changing Scientific Knowledge · Science, ages 9 to 11 · LightMySky