LightMySky

Substitution Against Elimination: Predicting the Major Product

Four mechanisms compete for the same substrate and the same reagent. Deciding which wins is a repeatable procedure over substrate class, base or nucleophile strength, bulk and temperature.

No account needed. Progress saves in this browser.

What a learner can do afterwards

  • Works through substrate class first and rules out the mechanisms it forbids
  • Separates nucleophile strength from base strength and uses each in the right place
  • Explains why a bulky base pushes a reaction towards elimination and towards the less substituted alkene
  • Predicts the effect of raising the temperature and gives the thermodynamic reason

1 · Read

Four mechanisms compete for the same substrate and the same reagent. Start with the substrate class, because it rules routes out before reagent details matter. Methyl and primary forbid SN1 and E1. Tertiary forbid SN2. Secondary keep all four routes open and need the full analysis.

Separate nucleophile strength from base strength and use each in the right place. Nucleophile strength is about attacking carbon, where loose polarizable electrons win. Base strength is about grabbing protons. Iodide is a great nucleophile but a weak base. A small strong nucleophile that is a weak base attacks carbon and substitutes.

Try it together

Give a tertiary halide a hindered alkoxide in warm alcohol and elimination dominates. The bulky base cannot easily reach carbon past the bulk, so it pulls an exposed proton instead. It takes the least hindered proton, giving the less substituted Hofmann alkene. Swap in a small good nucleophile like iodide and substitution takes over.

Good to know

Let solvent and temperature nudge the balance. Protic solvents favour ionization routes, while heat favours elimination because breaking one molecule into two gains disorder. Bimolecular routes speed up when the reagent concentration rises, while unimolecular routes ignore it. Work the tree in order: substrate, reagent, solvent, temperature.

Filter by substrate first, then read the reagent, then let solvent and heat settle the rest.

2 · Watch

Take it off screen

Print a worksheetA4 with an answer key page for grown-ups. No screen, no internet.

Where it sits

Then practise

8 questions wait behind this lesson, each with its answer explained. Every answer feeds the sky: stars light as they are learned, and dim when it is time to come back.

Spotted a problem on this page? Tell us
Substitution Against Elimination: Predicting the Major Product · Science, ages 19 to 21 · LightMySky